Fraud Prevention Success Story

How SecureTech Solutions Reduced Phone Fraud by 85% and Saved $2.3M Annually

SecureTech Solutions8 min read

As a fintech startup processing over $50M in monthly transactions, we were losing $180K per month to phone-based fraud. Here's how implementing a comprehensive phone validation strategy turned our security posture around and delivered a 10x ROI in the first quarter.

The Results: Before vs After Phone Validation

Before Implementation

Monthly Fraud Losses:$180,000
Fraud Rate:8.2%
Chargeback Ratio:0.82%
Manual Reviews:3,200/month

After 6 Months

Monthly Fraud Losses:$27,000
Fraud Rate:1.23%
Chargeback Ratio:0.15%
Manual Reviews:480/month
Annual Savings: $2.3 Million
ROI: 10x in First Quarter

The Breaking Point: When We Knew Something Had to Change

It was a Tuesday morning when our fraud alert system pinged. Another $12,000 transaction from a VoIP number that we'd approved just 24 hours earlier. This was the third time that week. Our fraud team was overwhelmed, manual review processes were buckling, and our payment processor was threatening to increase our fees due to rising chargeback ratios.

As Chief Security Officer at SecureTech Solutions, I was looking at a fraud problem that was growing faster than our business. We had implemented basic security measures, but fraudsters were getting more sophisticated. They were using disposable phone numbers, cycling through virtual carriers, and exploiting gaps in our verification system.

The Wake-Up Call

In Q2 2023, we lost $540,000 to phone-based fraud. Our existing verification system caught only basic invalid numbers, but sophisticated fraudsters were using legitimate-looking VoIP and virtual numbers to bypass our defenses.

Understanding Our Fraud Problem

We needed to understand exactly how fraudsters were exploiting our system. After analyzing 3 months of fraud data, we identified several patterns:

SMS Pumping Attacks (42% of fraud)

Fraudsters were using premium rate numbers to generate revenue from our SMS verification system. Each time we sent an OTP code, they were earning $2-5 per message.

VoIP Account Creation (35% of fraud)

Automated systems were using virtual phone numbers to create multiple fake accounts, exploiting our promotional offers and attempting coordinated attacks.

OTP Bypass Attempts (23% of fraud)

Sophisticated attackers were using multiple virtual numbers to bypass our two-factor authentication systems and gain access to legitimate user accounts.

The Search for a Comprehensive Solution

We evaluated multiple phone validation solutions, but most focused only on basic validation (checking if a number exists). We needed something more sophisticated:

Our Requirements

  • Real-time VoIP and virtual number detection
  • Carrier risk scoring and reputation analysis
  • Premium rate number identification
  • Integration with existing fraud detection systems
  • Global coverage for our international expansion

Why Phone-Check.app Won

  • 99.8% accuracy in VoIP detection
  • 25+ risk indicators for comprehensive scoring
  • 50ms response time (no UX impact)
  • Coverage across 232 countries
  • Simple REST API with great documentation

Implementation Strategy: Phased Rollout

We didn't want to disrupt our user experience, so we implemented phone validation in phases:

1Week 1-2: Shadow Mode

We integrated the API but didn't block any transactions. Instead, we logged all risk scores and compared them against actual fraud outcomes. This helped us establish baseline risk thresholds without impacting legitimate users.

2Week 3-4: High-Risk Blocking

We started blocking only the highest-risk numbers (VoIP + premium rate + known fraud patterns). This immediately stopped 60% of fraudulent attempts while affecting less than 0.1% of legitimate users.

3Week 5-8: Risk-Based Authentication

We implemented graduated responses based on risk scores. Medium-risk numbers required additional verification, while low-risk numbers sailed through. This optimized both security and user experience.

The Technical Implementation

Our engineering team integrated Phone-Check.app into our existing fraud detection pipeline. Here's the key integration points:

// API Integration Example
async function validatePhoneNumber(phoneNumber, allowVoIP = false) {
  try {
    const response = await fetch(`https://api.phone-check.app/v1-get-phone-details?phone=${phoneNumber}`, {
      method: 'GET',
      headers: {
        'accept': 'application/json',
        'x-api-key': 'YOUR_API_KEY'
      }
    });

    const result = await response.json();

    // Risk-based decision logic based on phone validation
    if (!result.valid) {
      // Block: Invalid phone number
      return { allowed: false, reason: 'Invalid phone number' };
    } else if (result.isDisposable) {
      // Block: Disposable phone number
      return { allowed: false, reason: 'Disposable phone number detected' };
    } else if (result.type === 'VOIP' && !allowVoIP) {
      // Block: VoIP number (if not allowed)
      return { allowed: false, reason: 'VoIP numbers not allowed' };
    } else {
      // Allow: Valid phone number
      return {
        allowed: true,
        phone: result.number,
        carrier: result.carrier,
        country: result.country,
        geo: result.geo
      };
    }
  } catch (error) {
    // Fail securely: deny on API errors
    return { allowed: false, reason: 'Validation service unavailable' };
  }
}

Measuring Success: The First 90 Days

The results exceeded our wildest expectations. Within the first 90 days, we saw dramatic improvements across all our key metrics:

85%
Fraud Reduction
99.8%
VoIP Detection Rate
50ms
Avg. Response Time
0.1%
False Positive Rate

Unexpected Benefits Beyond Fraud Prevention

While fraud reduction was our primary goal, we discovered several additional benefits:

Improved Customer Onboarding

Valid phone numbers reduced support tickets related to verification issues by 67%

Better Customer Communication

SMS delivery rates improved from 87% to 99.6%, reducing communication costs

Regulatory Compliance

Easier KYC and AML compliance with verified phone numbers

Reduced Operational Costs

Manual review workload decreased by 85%, freeing up fraud team resources

Challenges We Overcame

The implementation wasn't without challenges. Here's what we learned:

Key Challenges & Solutions

Challenge: Initial False Positives

Solution: Fine-tuned risk thresholds and added manual review for edge cases

Challenge: International Number Coverage

Solution: Used Phone-Check.app's global database covering 232 countries

Challenge: Integration Legacy Systems

Solution: Created middleware service to bridge old and new systems

The ROI Calculation

For the skeptics in the room (including our CFO), here's the hard math:

First Quarter ROI Analysis

Implementation Cost:-$45,000
Fraud Savings (Q1):+$459,000
Reduced Manual Review Costs:+$67,000
Lower Chargeback Fees:+$124,000
Net Q1 Return:+$605,000
ROI: 1,344% in First Quarter

Lessons Learned

After six months of implementation, here are our key takeaways:

1. Start with Data, Not Assumptions

Our shadow mode phase was crucial. It helped us understand our specific fraud patterns before implementing blocking rules.

2. Balance Security and User Experience

Risk-based authentication rather than blocking all suspicious numbers helped us maintain a smooth user experience.

3. Monitor and Iterate

Fraud patterns evolve. We continuously monitor performance and adjust our risk thresholds accordingly.

Looking Ahead

Phone validation has become a cornerstone of our security strategy. We're now exploring:

  • Machine learning models that combine phone validation with behavioral analysis
  • Real-time fraud pattern sharing with industry partners
  • Expanded use of phone validation in customer support and authentication flows

Final Thoughts

Implementing comprehensive phone validation was one of the best business decisions we made in 2023. The $2.3M annual savings are impressive, but the real value is in the confidence we now have in our user verification process.

For any fintech company dealing with fraud, I can't recommend phone validation highly enough. It's not just about blocking bad actors—it's about creating a trustworthy ecosystem where legitimate customers can transact safely and efficiently.

"The best time to implement phone validation was yesterday. The second best time is now. Every day you wait is another day fraudsters have to exploit your vulnerabilities."

— CSO, SecureTech Solutions

Ready to Transform Your Fraud Prevention?

Join companies like SecureTech Solutions that are saving millions with advanced phone validation technology.